How NOT to run an airport wifi system
February 23 2005
I'm sitting in the Lufthansa lounge at
Dortmund's airport. My flight, which was supposed to depart at 6:05
AM, is delayed to 8:30 AM due to weather in Munich. Big time problem,
since dad's flight will arrive at MUC at 8:20 AM. Ah well,
he has "just in case" instructions... didn't think I'd have to
use them. I probably should have found a way to get there last night.
Dortmund is what my friend Howard once
described as an AFA -- amenity-free airport. Nine gates, with only
a small coffee shop and duty free store on this side of security. Surprised
they even have a lounge -- though notably, it's unstaffed.
Sitting here with this extended delay,
I was curious to see if there was a wifi service available. I turned
the wifi on and got an IP rather quickly. Good sign. When I
launched the browser, I was presented with a "HotSpot-Ticket"
login screen from DOKOM, all auf Deutsch.. There was no obvious
link anywhere for a way to buy a login. However, a few links on the
right side of the screen were indicated as free sites, including Dokom's
own. There, I learned
that HotSpot-Tickets are available
for one, two, or 24 hours. The site informs that DOKOM HotSpot-Tickets
are for sale in many places, including Stockholmer Allee 24 in Dortmund.
For what it's worth, the Steigenberger
MAXX hotel here in Dortmund used a similiar system -- I had to buy an access
card at the hotel front desk; the card contained a userid/password used
to sign onto the wifi. That's ok in a hotel -- but sitting in an
airport? I should be able to put in a credit card number and go --
or, perhaps, use my T-Mobile sign-on, or perhaps the wifi should be free
(he laughs). But no, a physical card is required.
Well, this is Germany, so I thought
that perhaps I could buy the HotSpot-Ticket somewhere in the airport. I
wandered down the concourse to the coffee shop and duty-free shop -- no
luck. Frustrated, I picked up a printed "Dortmund Airport guide",
to see if it had any information. Indeed, it had good news -- WLAN
cards are available for sale at the airport information desk. Hmm,
that must be the airport information desk located before entering security.
As an added bonus, there is no obvious way to get from the departure
gate area back outside security -- there is simply no exit!
So, Dortmund Airport proprietors, I
suggest that it would be to your benefit to find another way to manage
this airport's WLAN. A delayed passenger is one of the likeliest
customers for this service, yet has no way to procure it. Thankfully,
I've got Lotus Notes and a bunch of replicated applications to work with
locally while I am waiting, but it would have been nice to be able to get
online.
Post a Comment
- 2
Ed Brill www.edbrill.com | 2/24/2005 1:23:28 AM
I'm not sure comparing Tijuana to wifi in Germany is a fair comparsion. In general, my technology experiences in Germany are far more advanced than almost anywhere else in the world, often including the US. For example, my Sunday flight home will have in-flight wi-fi -- which the FCC/FAA haven't approved for US commercial airlines yet.



I am constantly amazed by how backwards technology is in different industries or countries. Occasainally I go to TJ and when I walk down there, there is almost no computers whatsoever. Another example is going to the auto parts store and they almost all run on terminal based systems.